diff --git a/src/singletons/Settings.hpp b/src/singletons/Settings.hpp
index 6a17024d2..2dd350552 100644
--- a/src/singletons/Settings.hpp
+++ b/src/singletons/Settings.hpp
@@ -173,9 +173,9 @@ public:
                                             "qrc:/sounds/ping3.wav"};
 
     BoolSetting notificationToast = {"/notifications/enableToast", false};
-    QStringSetting openFromToast = {
+    IntSetting openFromToast = {
         "/notifications/openFromToast",
-        Toasts::findStringFromReaction(ToastReactions::openInBrowser)};
+        static_cast<int>(ToastReactions::OpenInBrowser)};
 
     /// External tools
     // Streamlink
diff --git a/src/singletons/Toasts.cpp b/src/singletons/Toasts.cpp
index 2352cccd0..96a640a1d 100644
--- a/src/singletons/Toasts.cpp
+++ b/src/singletons/Toasts.cpp
@@ -28,16 +28,16 @@
 namespace chatterino {
 
 std::map<ToastReactions, QString> Toasts::reactionToString = {
-    {ToastReactions::openInBrowser, OPEN_IN_BROWSER},
-    {ToastReactions::openInPlayer, OPEN_PLAYER_IN_BROWSER},
-    {ToastReactions::openInStreamlink, OPEN_IN_STREAMLINK},
-    {ToastReactions::dontOpen, DONT_OPEN}};
+    {ToastReactions::OpenInBrowser, OPEN_IN_BROWSER},
+    {ToastReactions::OpenInPlayer, OPEN_PLAYER_IN_BROWSER},
+    {ToastReactions::OpenInStreamlink, OPEN_IN_STREAMLINK},
+    {ToastReactions::DontOpen, DONT_OPEN}};
 
 std::map<QString, ToastReactions> Toasts::stringToReaction = {
-    {OPEN_IN_BROWSER, ToastReactions::openInBrowser},
-    {OPEN_PLAYER_IN_BROWSER, ToastReactions::openInPlayer},
-    {OPEN_IN_STREAMLINK, ToastReactions::openInStreamlink},
-    {DONT_OPEN, ToastReactions::dontOpen}};
+    {OPEN_IN_BROWSER, ToastReactions::OpenInBrowser},
+    {OPEN_PLAYER_IN_BROWSER, ToastReactions::OpenInPlayer},
+    {OPEN_IN_STREAMLINK, ToastReactions::OpenInStreamlink},
+    {DONT_OPEN, ToastReactions::DontOpen}};
 
 bool Toasts::isEnabled()
 {
@@ -61,6 +61,13 @@ QString Toasts::findStringFromReaction(const ToastReactions &reaction)
     }
 }
 
+QString Toasts::findStringFromReaction(
+    const pajlada::Settings::Setting<int> &value)
+{
+    int i = static_cast<int>(value);
+    return Toasts::findStringFromReaction(static_cast<ToastReactions>(i));
+}
+
 ToastReactions Toasts::findReactionFromString(const QString &string)
 {
     auto iterator = Toasts::stringToReaction.find(string);
@@ -70,7 +77,7 @@ ToastReactions Toasts::findReactionFromString(const QString &string)
     }
     else
     {
-        return ToastReactions::dontOpen;
+        return ToastReactions::DontOpen;
     }
 }
 void Toasts::sendChannelNotification(const QString &channelName, Platform p)
@@ -125,23 +132,24 @@ public:
     void toastActivated() const
     {
         QString link;
-        switch (Toasts::findReactionFromString(getSettings()->openFromToast))
+        switch (static_cast<ToastReactions>(
+            getSettings()->openFromToast.getValue()))
         {
-            case ToastReactions::openInBrowser:
+            case ToastReactions::OpenInBrowser:
                 if (platform_ == Platform::Twitch)
                 {
                     link = "http://www.twitch.tv/" + channelName_;
                 }
                 QDesktopServices::openUrl(QUrl(link));
                 break;
-            case ToastReactions::openInPlayer:
+            case ToastReactions::OpenInPlayer:
                 if (platform_ == Platform::Twitch)
                 {
                     link = "https://player.twitch.tv/?channel=" + channelName_;
                 }
                 QDesktopServices::openUrl(QUrl(link));
                 break;
-            case ToastReactions::openInStreamlink:
+            case ToastReactions::OpenInStreamlink:
             {
                 openStreamlinkForChannel(channelName_);
                 break;
@@ -173,10 +181,11 @@ void Toasts::sendWindowsNotification(const QString &channelName, Platform p)
     std::wstring widestr = std::wstring(utf8_text.begin(), utf8_text.end());
 
     templ.setTextField(widestr, WinToastLib::WinToastTemplate::FirstLine);
-    if (Toasts::findReactionFromString(getSettings()->openFromToast) !=
-        ToastReactions::dontOpen)
+    if (static_cast<ToastReactions>(getSettings()->openFromToast.getValue()) !=
+        ToastReactions::DontOpen)
     {
-        QString mode = getSettings()->openFromToast;
+        QString mode =
+            Toasts::findStringFromReaction(getSettings()->openFromToast);
         mode = mode.toLower();
 
         templ.setTextField(L"Click here to " + mode.toStdWString(),
diff --git a/src/singletons/Toasts.hpp b/src/singletons/Toasts.hpp
index a7ea91861..a8a51e56b 100644
--- a/src/singletons/Toasts.hpp
+++ b/src/singletons/Toasts.hpp
@@ -8,10 +8,10 @@ namespace chatterino {
 enum class Platform : uint8_t;
 
 enum class ToastReactions {
-    openInBrowser,
-    openInPlayer,
-    openInStreamlink,
-    dontOpen
+    OpenInBrowser = 0,
+    OpenInPlayer = 1,
+    OpenInStreamlink = 2,
+    DontOpen = 3
 };
 
 class Toasts final : public Singleton
@@ -19,6 +19,8 @@ class Toasts final : public Singleton
 public:
     void sendChannelNotification(const QString &channelName, Platform p);
     static QString findStringFromReaction(const ToastReactions &reaction);
+    static QString findStringFromReaction(
+        const pajlada::Settings::Setting<int> &reaction);
     static ToastReactions findReactionFromString(const QString &string);
     static std::map<ToastReactions, QString> reactionToString;
     static std::map<QString, ToastReactions> stringToReaction;
diff --git a/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.cpp b/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.cpp
index 85aab7bb0..dfbc5574e 100644
--- a/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.cpp
+++ b/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.cpp
@@ -24,7 +24,6 @@ NotificationPage::NotificationPage()
     : SettingsPage("Notifications", ":/settings/notification2.svg")
 {
     LayoutCreator<NotificationPage> layoutCreator(this);
-
     auto layout = layoutCreator.emplace<QVBoxLayout>().withoutMargin();
     {
         auto tabs = layout.emplace<QTabWidget>();
@@ -46,17 +45,12 @@ NotificationPage::NotificationPage()
                         ->setSizePolicy(QSizePolicy::Maximum,
                                         QSizePolicy::Preferred);
 
+                    // implementation of custom combobox done
+                    // because addComboBox only can handle strings-settings
+                    // int setting for the ToastReaction is desired
                     openIn
-                        .append(this->createComboBox(
-                            {Toasts::findStringFromReaction(
-                                 ToastReactions::openInBrowser),
-                             Toasts::findStringFromReaction(
-                                 ToastReactions::openInPlayer),
-                             Toasts::findStringFromReaction(
-                                 ToastReactions::openInStreamlink),
-                             Toasts::findStringFromReaction(
-                                 ToastReactions::dontOpen)},
-                            getSettings()->openFromToast))
+                        .append(this->createToastReactionComboBox(
+                            this->managedConnections_))
                         ->setSizePolicy(QSizePolicy::Maximum,
                                         QSizePolicy::Preferred);
                 }
@@ -140,4 +134,31 @@ NotificationPage::NotificationPage()
         }
     }
 }
+QComboBox *NotificationPage::createToastReactionComboBox(
+    std::vector<pajlada::Signals::ScopedConnection> managedConnections)
+{
+    QComboBox *toastReactionOptions = new QComboBox();
+
+    for (int i = 0; i <= static_cast<int>(ToastReactions::DontOpen); i++)
+    {
+        toastReactionOptions->insertItem(
+            i, Toasts::findStringFromReaction(static_cast<ToastReactions>(i)));
+    }
+
+    // update when setting changes
+    pajlada::Settings::Setting<int> setting = getSettings()->openFromToast;
+    setting.connect(
+        [toastReactionOptions](const int &index, auto) {
+            toastReactionOptions->setCurrentIndex(index);
+        },
+        managedConnections);
+
+    QObject::connect(toastReactionOptions, &QComboBox::currentTextChanged,
+                     [setting](const QString &newValue) {
+                         getSettings()->openFromToast.setValue(static_cast<int>(
+                             Toasts::findReactionFromString(newValue)));
+                     });
+
+    return toastReactionOptions;
+}
 }  // namespace chatterino
diff --git a/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.hpp b/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.hpp
index d0e8c12a2..e70f58ad4 100644
--- a/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.hpp
+++ b/src/widgets/settingspages/NotificationPage.hpp
@@ -15,6 +15,8 @@ public:
     NotificationPage();
 
 private:
+    QComboBox *createToastReactionComboBox(
+        std::vector<pajlada::Signals::ScopedConnection> managedConnections);
 };
 
 }  // namespace chatterino